BMW · 18 model years

BMW 5 Series by year

This page brings together every NHTSA safety recall, owner complaint, EPA fuel economy figure and crash test rating we hold for the BMW 5 Series, covering model years 1995 to 2023 (18 years in all).

Across those years owners have filed 426 complaints. The 2008 stands out with 105 (25% of the total), ahead of the 2006 with 85.

Over the whole run, the air bags accounts for the most complaints (94, 22%), with the engine second (69).

Owner complaints by model year

Each column is one model year; select it to open that year. Newer years have had less time on the road, so expect lower counts.

Years with the most complaints

Years with the fewest complaints

Only years at least three model years old are compared. Low counts can also reflect low sales.

Every BMW 5 Series model year

Problems across all years

Fuel economy by year

YearCityHighwayCombinedFuelConfigurations
2023 253328 MPG Premium7
2012 233427 MPG Premium12
2011 213125 MPG Premium11
2010 182822 MPG Premium15
2009 182821 MPG Premium12
2008 182821 MPG Premium12
2007 182822 MPG Premium14
2006 182821 MPG Premium14
2005 182721 MPG Premium8
2004 192822 MPG Premium9
2003 182722 MPG Premium10
2002 182722 MPG Premium10
2001 182721 MPG Premium10
2000 182621 MPG Premium10
1999 182621 MPG Regular8
1997 182621 MPG Premium4
1995 172620 MPG Premium8

EPA figures for the most efficient configuration of each year.

Common questions about the BMW 5 Series

What is the worst year for the BMW 5 Series?

By owner complaints filed with NHTSA, the 2008 BMW 5 Series has the most, with 105, followed by the 2006 with 85.

Which BMW 5 Series years have the fewest complaints?

Among model years at least three years old, the 1996, 2023, and 1997 have the fewest complaints on file. Complaint counts also depend on how many were sold, so a rare year can look better than it is.

Other BMW models