BMW · M Roadster

1999 BMW M Roadster Problems

Two-seater · RWD · Regular

Owners have filed 18 complaints about the 1999 BMW M Roadster with NHTSA's vehicle safety hotline and website. The body and structure leads with 9, then the suspension with 5.

One complaint can name more than one system, so the groups below add up to more than the total. Open a group for the parts owners name, the mileage and their own words.

  • Body and structure 50% of complaints · median 82,000 miles · Frame And Members 9
  • Suspension 28% of complaints · median 79,000 miles · Rear 5
  • Transmission and drivetrain 28% of complaints · median 75,000 miles · Driveline 5
  • Air bags 11% of complaints · median 41,000 miles · Frontal 2
  • Other or unknown 6% of complaints 1
  • Seats 6% of complaints · median 29,000 miles 1
  • Visibility and wipers 6% of complaints · Rearview Mirrors/Devices 1

Latest owner reports

Suspension Filed Sep 2015 90,019 miles NC

Over several months I heard increasing noise from the rear of my car. When I took it to my mechanic he found that the entire crossmember that holds the differential to the subframe had pulled loose from the trunk. The car could not be safely driven, my bodyshop suggested I send it to the BMW dealer in charlotte nc. They kept my car for about 3 weeks and fixed it. Now 5 years and 10k miles have passed and the sub-frame mount is pulling loose again, the welds pop out and the noise has started. It makes the car dangerous to drive and impossible to sell.

Owner complaint 10764225 filed with NHTSA
Transmission and drivetrain Filed Jul 2015 145,000 miles WA

Took vehicle in for engine maintenance and asked them to address squeaks and rattles. On inspection it was found that the rear crossmember had almost completely separated from the unibody and the mount holding the differential in had only 1/4 in of 4 inches holding the aft end of the differential. Complete failure could have caused a catastrophic chain of events causing a crash and possible fatalities. Looking on line I found numerous failures of the same kind resulting from metal fatigue brought on by faulty design. AT least this was the opinion of other people with the same failure. One person had a phds in metallurgy.

Owner complaint 10744495 filed with NHTSA
Suspension Filed Jul 2015 145,000 miles WA

Took vehicle in for engine maintenance and asked them to address squeaks and rattles. On inspection it was found that the rear crossmember had almost completely separated from the unibody and the mount holding the differential in had only 1/4 in of 4 inches holding the aft end of the differential. Complete failure could have caused a catastrophic chain of events causing a crash and possible fatalities. Looking on line I found numerous failures of the same kind resulting from metal fatigue brought on by faulty design. AT least this was the opinion of other people with the same failure. One person had a phds in metallurgy.

Owner complaint 10744495 filed with NHTSA
Body and structure Filed Mar 2012 67,000 miles LA

While driving the car, the rear end fail and began to drag. After getting the car towed to the shop, it was noted the rear end subframe welds came lose. After contacting the insurance company they totaled the car out. I bought the car back and made repairs to the car that cost me $4000.00.

Owner complaint 10451824 filed with NHTSA