2016 BMW X1 Transmission and drivetrain Problems
Large car · AWD · Premium
Owners of the 2016 BMW X1 have reported 33 transmission problems to NHTSA, 21% of all complaints about this model year.
Where owners named a specific part, the most common were automatic transmission (3).
The typical report came at around 67,000 miles, and complaints were filed between February 2017 and April 2025.
For comparison, the 2017 X1 has the most transmission complaints of any year, with 57.
Automatic and manual transmissions, CVTs, clutches, axles, driveshafts and transfer cases: harsh or delayed shifts, slipping, shuddering and rolling away in park.
Parts named in these complaints
- Automatic Transmission3
Owners choose these labels when they file, so they are a guide rather than a diagnosis.
What owners say
The car is indicating the I need to press the parking brake to secure the car from rolling after I have placed it in park and pressed the electronic parking brake.
The contact owns a 2016 BMW X1. The contact stated that after arriving to the destination and shifting the vehicle into park(P), the message "Secure Vehicle against Rolling Malfunction" was displayed. There was no warning light illuminated. The vehicle was taken to the dealer, who diagnosed a failure with the transmission shifter lever control cable. The contact was informed that the transmission shifter lever control cable was abnormally stretched. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was not notified of the failure. The failure mileage was 46,000.
The transmission lock sensor is defective in this car design- the spring in the gearshift assembly that contacts the transmission lock sensor has a faulty design and is prone to breaking. This leads to a warning in the car that the transmission lock has not occurred when the car is in park (although it is actually functioning). This creates a "false alarm" situation that then does not allow the user to know if the transmission is truly locked in park This defect has occurred in my car as diagnosed by both dealer and independent mechanic. This is a common and known defect amongst X1 owners (as well as the mechanical sibling Mini Cooper).
Transmission and drivetrain complaints across X1 years
Questions about transmission and drivetrain problems
How common are transmission and drivetrain problems on the 2016 BMW X1?
33 owners have reported transmission and drivetrain problems to NHTSA, 21% of all complaints for this model year.