Subaru · Legacy

1999 Subaru Legacy Transmission and drivetrain Problems

Compact car · 4WD/AWD · Regular

Owners of the 1999 Subaru Legacy have reported 18 transmission problems to NHTSA, 19% of all complaints about this model year.

Where owners named a specific part, the most common were automatic transmission (11), axle assembly (1), and manual transmission (1).

The typical report came at around 92,000 miles, and complaints were filed between July 1999 and July 2014.

For comparison, the 2010 Legacy has the most transmission complaints of any year, with 50.

Automatic and manual transmissions, CVTs, clutches, axles, driveshafts and transfer cases: harsh or delayed shifts, slipping, shuddering and rolling away in park.

Complaints18
Typical mileage92k
Crashes / fires0 / 0
Injuries0

Parts named in these complaints

  • Automatic Transmission11
  • Axle Assembly1
  • Manual Transmission1
  • Clutch Assembly1

Owners choose these labels when they file, so they are a guide rather than a diagnosis.

What owners say

Transmission and drivetrain Filed Jul 2014 134,700 miles PA

Driving in heavy traffic in the left lane of I-78, the shifter popped out of 5th gear by itself (that is, without any human intervention). The vehicle completely lost power immediately, as it was now in neutral.

Owner complaint 10616335 filed with NHTSA
Transmission and drivetrain Filed Mar 2011 141,225 miles CA

Automatic transmission problem: hesitates going into gear. Get stuck in neutral. Shift through the gears to see if it will go into gear. Then try revving engine to slip it into gear. It CAN suddenly catch into gear and then the car surges forward or backwards, causing a dangerous situation. According to complaint sites on the internet, this is a common problem in 5 years of Subaru vehicles. This is not acceptable. Repair shop said the seals are "going" and I will likely need a new or rebuilt transmission. Subaru should acknowledge the problem and offer a free fix.

Owner complaint 10392215 filed with NHTSA

Transmission and drivetrain complaints across Legacy years

Questions about transmission and drivetrain problems

How common are transmission and drivetrain problems on the 1999 Subaru Legacy?

18 owners have reported transmission and drivetrain problems to NHTSA, 19% of all complaints for this model year.