Subaru · Legacy

2005 Subaru Legacy Engine Problems

Compact car · 4WD/AWD · Premium

Owners of the 2005 Subaru Legacy have reported 33 engine problems to NHTSA, 18% of all complaints about this model year.

Where owners named a specific part, the most common were engine (23) and exhaust system (3).

The typical report came at around 48,000 miles, and complaints were filed between November 2004 and August 2015.

These engine complaints include 1 crash, 1 fire, and 1 injury.

For comparison, the 2010 Legacy has the most engine complaints of any year, with 35.

Engine and cooling: stalling, loss of power, oil consumption, overheating, knocking, failed internal parts and check-engine faults traced to the engine.

Complaints33
Typical mileage48k
Crashes / fires1 / 1
Injuries1

Parts named in these complaints

  • Engine23
  • Exhaust System3

Owners choose these labels when they file, so they are a guide rather than a diagnosis.

What owners say

Engine Filed Aug 2015 125,000 miles NY

As we were driving down the highway, we heard what sounded like a airplane propeller whirling. The car then stopped. The mechanic AT the Subaru dealership said we blew a cylinder. The car is now in need of a new engine or will be scrapped. We kept the car service religiously and was in great shape. How does this happen? I thought we had a reliable car.

Owner complaint 10748165 filed with NHTSA
Engine Filed Aug 2014 11,500 miles MO

The 2005 suburu suddenly stops no matter weather going 35 MPH or 70mph without warning! Later the engine warning flashes, then the cruise control flashes, after abt. 20 seconds it starts, but stops intermittently w/o warning. Life/death risk.just bought it 5 mos. Ago. The turbo malfunctions--cracks.

Owner complaint 10629179 filed with NHTSA
Engine Filed Feb 2014 81,000 miles IL

The vehicles turbo failed and destroyed the engine. The turbo and engine were all factory original. I replaced the part that I thought was causing problems with the engine and turned the car on and black smoke came out off the exhaust. According to the mechanic shop I took it to the oil union bolts are the cause of the problem to starving oil to the turbo and then the turbo fails. I think it is unclear that these engines have a major flaw in them. Most people have these problems way before the 100,000 miles on the odometer mark. I would need a completely new engine for the vehicle.

Owner complaint 10564696 filed with NHTSA

Engine complaints across Legacy years

Questions about engine problems

How common are engine problems on the 2005 Subaru Legacy?

33 owners have reported engine problems to NHTSA, 18% of all complaints for this model year.