Unintended Acceleration Complaints: What NHTSA Has Found

Sudden unintended acceleration is one of the most frightening complaints in the NHTSA database. Here is what investigations have actually found, from floor mats to pedal mix-ups.

Unintended Acceleration Complaints: What NHTSA Has Found

Unintended acceleration complaints describe a car speeding up when the driver says they did not press the gas, or failing to slow when they pressed the brake. NHTSA has investigated these reports for decades. Some had mechanical causes, most famously the Toyota floor mat and sticky pedal recalls of 2009 and 2010. Many others, after investigation, were attributed to pedal misapplication, where the driver pressed the accelerator believing it was the brake. Both things are true at once, which is why these cases are so contentious.

How NHTSA handles these complaints

Unintended acceleration reports usually land under the "speed control" or "vehicle speed control" category in the complaint database. When reports cluster on a model, NHTSA can open a preliminary evaluation, request data from the manufacturer, inspect vehicles and review event data recorders. Owners and advocacy groups can also file a defect petition asking NHTSA to open an investigation. NHTSA grants some petitions and denies others, and publishes its reasoning either way.

Event data recorders, which most modern cars have, are a major tool. They store a few seconds of data before a crash, including throttle position and whether the brake was applied. In many investigated crashes, that data showed the accelerator at or near full and no brake application.

The Toyota recalls of 2009 and 2010

Toyota's sudden acceleration crisis is the best-known case. Two physical causes were identified and recalled:

  1. Floor mat entrapment. In 2009 Toyota recalled millions of vehicles because an unsecured or incompatible floor mat, particularly a heavy all-weather mat or a mat stacked on top of another, could trap the accelerator pedal in a pressed position. The fix included reshaping or replacing the pedal and, on some models, modifying the floor.
  2. Sticky pedals. In early 2010 Toyota recalled millions more vehicles because the friction mechanism in certain accelerator pedal assemblies could wear and cause the pedal to return slowly or stick partly open. Dealers installed a reinforcement bar to fix it.

Toyota also added brake override software to many vehicles. Lexus models were included in parts of the recalls as well.

NHTSA then asked NASA engineers to examine Toyota's electronic throttle control for software or electronic faults. The resulting 2011 report found no electronic cause for the large-scale problem, while acknowledging that no study can prove the absence of every possible fault. Toyota later reached a deferred prosecution agreement with the Justice Department over how it had disclosed the problems.

The complaint data shows the effect. Owners have filed 2,888 complaints with NHTSA about the 2007 Toyota Camry, and the 2007 Camry speed control complaints rose sharply as the story became national news. The 2009 Corolla recalls and 2010 Prius recalls pages list campaigns from that period. As we explain in how to read NHTSA complaint data, media attention drives filing spikes, which makes complaint totals during a news cycle hard to interpret.

Pedal misapplication

NHTSA studies have found that drivers sometimes press the accelerator while believing they are pressing the brake. The driver feels the car surge, presses harder on what they think is the brake, and the car accelerates more. Afterwards the driver is often sincerely certain they were braking.

Research has linked pedal misapplication to certain situations: parking and pulling out of parking spaces, starting the car and shifting immediately, turning in the seat to look behind, and unfamiliarity with the vehicle. It is reported across all ages, with older and very young drivers somewhat overrepresented in some studies. It happens at low speeds far more than on the highway.

A more recent example: NHTSA reviewed a petition about sudden acceleration in Tesla vehicles and, in 2021, denied it, concluding from vehicle data that the cases it examined involved pedal misapplication rather than a vehicle defect. You can compare complaint patterns on the 2018 Tesla Model 3 problems page.

None of this means every unintended acceleration complaint is driver error. Mechanical problems such as floor mats, sticking pedals, damaged throttle cables on older cars and cruise control faults have been confirmed. It means investigators look at the evidence case by case.

Brake override

Brake override, also called smart pedal or brake-throttle override, cuts engine power when the brake and accelerator are pressed at the same time. If a floor mat or sticking pedal holds the throttle open, pressing the brake still reduces power and stops the car. After the Toyota recalls, automakers widely adopted the feature, and NHTSA proposed requiring it. Most vehicles sold in the US today have it.

Brake override does not help in a misapplication case, because the driver is not pressing the brake at all. Some newer vehicles use cameras and sensors to detect when a driver accelerates hard toward an obstacle at low speed and limit power, which targets that specific problem.

What to do if your car accelerates on its own

  • Press the brake firmly and hold it. Do not pump. Modern brakes can overpower an engine at full throttle if held hard and steadily.
  • Shift to neutral. This disconnects the engine from the wheels. The engine may rev loudly, but the car will slow.
  • Do not turn off the engine while moving unless you have no other option. On push-button cars, you typically must hold the button for several seconds, and you will lose power assist for steering and brakes.
  • Afterward, do not clear codes or alter the car. Have the dealer and, ideally, an independent expert inspect it and download event data.
  • Check floor mats in every car you drive. Use only mats designed for that vehicle, secured with the factory clips, and never stack them.

Frequently asked questions

Was Toyota unintended acceleration caused by electronics?

The NHTSA and NASA investigation published in 2011 did not find an electronic cause for the widespread reports. The recalls addressed floor mat entrapment and sticking pedals, which were confirmed mechanical causes.

Do all new cars have brake override?

Most new vehicles sold in the US have it, as automakers adopted it broadly after 2010. Check your owner's manual, or ask a dealer, to confirm for a specific model.

How do I report sudden acceleration?

File a complaint with NHTSA, including the VIN, speed, location type (parking lot, highway), what you did with the pedals and any dealer findings. Keep the car unaltered if a crash occurred, since event data can be important evidence.

By VehicleAlmanac Editorial · updated 2 Nov 2026

All articles

Keep reading