Subaru · Forester

1999 Subaru Forester Problems

SUV · 4WD/AWD · Regular

Owners have filed 131 complaints about the 1999 Subaru Forester with NHTSA's vehicle safety hotline and website. The transmission and drivetrain leads with 32, then the engine with 28. Reports for this year mention 5 crashes, 1 fire, and 5 injuries.

One complaint can name more than one system, so the groups below add up to more than the total. Open a group for the parts owners name, the mileage and their own words.

  • Transmission and drivetrain 24% of complaints · median 72,000 miles · Automatic Transmission 32
  • Engine 21% of complaints · median 87,000 miles · Engine 28
  • Suspension 19% of complaints · median 43,000 miles · Front 25
  • Brakes 15% of complaints · median 80,000 miles · Antilock/Traction Control/Electronic Limited Slip 19
  • Tires 5% of complaints · median 117,000 miles · Bead 7
  • Speed control 5% of complaints · median 49,000 miles · Linkages 6
  • Fuel system 4% of complaints · median 95,000 miles · Storage 5
  • Wheels 3% of complaints · median 16,000 miles 4
  • Electrical system 3% of complaints · median 175,000 miles · Ignition 4
  • Seat belts 3% of complaints · Front 4
  • Body and structure 2% of complaints · median 96,000 miles 3
  • Steering 2% of complaints · Hydraulic Power Assist System 3
  • Equipment and accessories 2% of complaints · median 29,000 miles · Mechanical 3
  • Air bags 2% of complaints · median 62,000 miles · Frontal 2
  • Visibility and wipers 2% of complaints · Windshield 2
  • Other or unknown 1% of complaints 1
  • Seats 1% of complaints 1

Latest owner reports

Engine Filed Feb 2020 MN

(partial copy of message I sent to Subaru earlier this week.) [my] Forester is old, but I wouldn't be replacing it if I didn't need another head gasket. You surely are aware of the problem your 4 cyl. Engines have had with failing head gaskets. Unfortunately, this is the second one experiencing such failure. I replaced the original one several years back AT my own expense. Let me state my unqualified case that I should not have had to pay for this replacement, as you--Subaru--knew well that gasket failure was in this car's future. How do I make this claim? Well, when I bought the car, it came with an additive in the radiator.

Owner complaint 11311985 filed with NHTSA
Brakes Filed Jul 2019 80,000 miles MD

Why is the brake line corrosion recall wqk-47 only for 2009-2013 foresters? I own a 1999 Forester which has just had a catastrophic brake line failure that is exactly the same as what is described in the recall. Corrosion of the brake lines is in the area of the junction block that is located under the car behind the area of the passenger seat. It seems that vehicle safety should not be dependent on the age of the vehicle, especially something as critical as the braking system. When the system failed, the brake pedal became very soft and I could feel it sinking toward the floor.

Owner complaint 11230370 filed with NHTSA
Engine Filed Apr 2017 170,000 miles MS

Tl* the contact owns a 1999 Subaru Forester. On several occasions, while driving, the engine overheated and seized. There were no warning indicators illuminated. The contact mentioned that the vehicle was previously repaired, but the failure recurred. The vehicle was not diagnosed or repaired. The manufacturer was not made aware of the issue. The failure mileage was 170,000.

Owner complaint 10970496 filed with NHTSA
Transmission and drivetrain Filed May 2016 89,000 miles CA

As others have stated here and many more from various Subaru forums, I've been dealing with the shifting into drive issue (it acts as if it's in neutral) with the AT. It CAN take several seconds to several minutes (and sometimes longer or not AT all) before it engages. I usually have to rev/pump the accelerator until it corrects itself. Once I'm in drive all is well as long as I stay that way. This is random until it starts to get worse over time. I've read that this is fairly common and it's a worn piston seal or something that prevents enough pressure for the forward gear to engage. This began in 2010 with only 89k miles.

Owner complaint 10871310 filed with NHTSA