Subaru · Forester

2016 Subaru Forester Fuel system Problems

Small SUV · AWD · Regular

Owners of the 2016 Subaru Forester have reported 24 fuel system problems to NHTSA, 6% of all complaints about this model year.

The typical report came at around 44,000 miles, and complaints were filed between December 2016 and September 2025.

These fuel system complaints include 5 crashes and 1 injury.

For comparison, the 2004 Forester has the most fuel system complaints of any year, with 124.

Fuel pumps, injectors, lines, tanks, filler necks and evaporative systems, gasoline and diesel, including leaks and fuel smell.

Complaints24
Typical mileage44k
Crashes / fires5 / 0
Injuries1

What owners say

Fuel system Filed Sep 2024 MI

As I said earlier: car stopped dead in the middle of I-94, going 70 mph. No reason--had 1/4 tank of gasoline, alternator working, etc. Come to find out that you all recalled 2018 Subaru Foresters for this EXACT same problem--cars stalling while driving. That was for a faulty fuel pump. Discussion boards by owners are FULL of the same exact problem from 2014-2019. You should issue a recall there too, IMHO, since obviously the 2018 are the tip of the iceberg!

Owner complaint 11613547 filed with NHTSA
Fuel system Filed Oct 2023 TX Crash

October 31, 2023 at approximately 11:45 am was slowly pulling in to HEB Curbside parking spot #[XXX] at 651 N U.S. 183 in Leander, Texas and the car accelerated at a high speed without touching the gas pedal. I responded with braking but it did not stop the crash in to the concrete pylon. The pylon is fine but my front end on the 2016 Subaru Forester is not. It will need extensive repair. I got a ride for myself and my groceries, notified my insurance company but unfortunately, I am only covered by liability insurance. I am very fortunate that no-one was hurt including myself.

Owner complaint 11552884 filed with NHTSA

Fuel system complaints across Forester years

Questions about fuel system problems

How common are fuel system problems on the 2016 Subaru Forester?

24 owners have reported fuel system problems to NHTSA, 6% of all complaints for this model year.