Can Dealers Sell Cars With Open Recalls?
Federal law treats new cars, used cars and rental cars very differently when a recall is open. Here is what dealers can and cannot do, where state rules come in, and how to protect yourself.
It depends on whether the car is new or used. Federal law prohibits dealers from selling or leasing a new vehicle that has an open safety recall until the defect is repaired. For used cars, there is generally no federal ban, so a used car dealer can legally sell a vehicle with an unrepaired recall in most situations. Rental car companies face their own, stricter federal rule. State laws add another layer, and they vary.
New cars: federal law says no
Under the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act, once a dealer is notified that a new vehicle in its inventory is covered by a safety recall, it may not sell or lease that vehicle until the remedy has been performed. This applies to new vehicles that have not yet been sold to a first retail buyer.
In practice, this is why you sometimes see new cars sitting on a lot with a "stop sale" tag. The automaker has issued a recall, and the dealer has to wait for parts or a software update before it can deliver the car. Manufacturers also issue their own stop-sale orders to dealers, sometimes before the recall is formally filed.
If you are buying new, you can reasonably expect the car to have no open recalls at delivery. It is still worth running the VIN through the NHTSA recall lookup before you sign, especially if the car has been in inventory for a while.
Used cars: generally allowed under federal law
The federal prohibition applies to new vehicles. Once a car has been sold to a retail buyer and later comes back as a trade-in or an auction purchase, federal law generally does not stop a dealer from reselling it with an open recall. That is true for franchised dealers selling used cars and for independent used car lots.
Safety advocates have pushed Congress for years to close this gap, and several bills have been introduced, but as of this writing there is no general federal requirement that used car dealers fix recalls before sale.
That does not mean anything goes. A few limits do apply:
- Advertising claims. The Federal Trade Commission has taken action against dealers and dealer groups that advertised used cars as thoroughly inspected or safe without disclosing open recalls. The FTC's position is that such claims can be deceptive if the car has an unrepaired safety recall that the buyer was not told about.
- Certified pre-owned programs. Many manufacturers require open recalls to be completed before a car can be sold as certified pre-owned. Program rules vary by brand, so ask.
- State law. Some states have considered or adopted disclosure requirements or other rules touching on recalls in used car sales. Rules differ from state to state and change over time, so check with your state attorney general's office or motor vehicle agency if it matters to your purchase.
Rental cars: a separate federal rule
Rental cars are covered by the Raechel and Jacqueline Houck Safe Rental Car Act, which became law in 2015 as part of a larger transportation bill. It is named after two sisters who were killed in 2004 when the rented Chrysler PT Cruiser they were driving caught fire and crashed. The car was under a recall for a power steering hose problem that could cause a fire, and it had not been repaired.
The law generally requires rental companies with fleets of 35 or more vehicles to stop renting, leasing or selling a vehicle once they receive notice of a safety recall that applies to it, until the vehicle has been fixed. There is a narrow allowance when the remedy is not yet available and the recall notice provides interim steps that make it safe to use the car, but a vehicle under a do not drive type warning must stay parked.
This matters for used car buyers too. Large rental fleets sell their used vehicles through auctions and their own retail lots, and under the act they are not supposed to sell a vehicle with an open recall.
Trade-ins and auctions
Many used cars pass through wholesale auctions or arrive as trade-ins before they reach a retail lot. Wholesale auctions often display open recall information on their listings, so the dealer buying the car may well know about the recall. That knowledge does not automatically reach you. A franchised dealer reselling a trade-in of its own brand has an easy path to fix it, since the manufacturer pays for the work. An independent lot without a service relationship with that brand is less likely to bother. Either way, run the VIN yourself rather than relying on what is written on the windshield.
Private sales
A private seller is not under any federal recall obligation at all. They may not even know about an open recall. That is not necessarily a problem, because you can check the VIN yourself and get the repair done for free after you buy. Our guide on buying a used car with an open recall walks through how to handle it.
How to protect yourself at a dealer
- Run the VIN yourself before negotiating. It is free and takes two minutes. Our guide on checking car recalls by VIN explains how.
- Ask the dealer in writing whether any recalls are open, and ask them to complete the repair before delivery. A franchised dealer for the same brand can usually do it on site.
- Get the commitment in the paperwork. A "due bill" or "we owe" form listing the recall repair is better than a verbal promise.
- Read the recall details. A missing label is one thing. A do not drive warning is another, and you should not take delivery until it is resolved.
- Look up the model year history. Our recalls pages show every recall for each make, model and year, so you know what to expect.
Frequently asked questions
Is it illegal to sell a used car with an open recall?
Not under federal law in most cases. The federal ban covers new vehicles and rental fleets. Some states have their own rules, so the answer can depend on where you buy.
Can a new car dealer sell me a car under a stop-sale order?
Not once the dealer has been notified of a safety recall covering that new vehicle. The car must be repaired first.
Who pays to fix a recall on a used car I bought from a dealer?
The manufacturer. Safety recall repairs are free at franchised dealers regardless of who owns the vehicle, within the federal 15-year age limit.
Are rental companies allowed to rent a car with an open recall?
Generally no, for companies with 35 or more vehicles. The Safe Rental Car Act requires them to fix the recall first, with a limited allowance for interim measures when parts are not yet available.